In My Song begins with Gene Iacono's "slate" as a tribute to him but also because it was a song that he had a strong emotional connection to. It's a simple ballad, full of longing for a lost or far away lover and is loosely based on the chord changes for Yesterday by the Beatles. David Chris's beautiful sax solo serves as a strong musical and emotional statement to complement the longing conveyed in the lyrics and melody. It was another favorite of listeners and one of Thin Ice's best.